Behind the scenes, the electronics industry is leaping into brave new worlds of printed electronics, electronic inks, laser Nano and other innovations. Quite frankly we don’t think any of these innovations will mightily impact the current trajectory of RFID as we know it today. But in our lifetime there will be radical changes.
A quick stroll of the past
It took a long time for RFID to get to today — the first billion tags. But the market is humming along now. And even now a stunning amount of innovations is going on to find the
Figure 1 has the first billion and Figure 2 has market trajectory into the future.
But our goal here for this article is not to look back, but to leap forward into the future.
Innovations for the Future
The future of electronics, RFID and antennas is quite interesting.1 Material innovations in organic polymers, Nano technology, metamaterials; and innovations in processing such as advances in photolithography, electron-beam lithography, direct laser/optical lithography, electrophoretic; new battery/power technologies — the whole area of printed electronics on organic new material, cloth and paper, all are in motion to step by step transform the semiconductor world. More flexible and cheaper production will enable a new generation of RFID growth.
These will have a huge impact on the market in the future. Though in Figure 2 we take a swag at the growth trajectory, we have to say that forecasters who focus on that may be a better source.2 Let’s look at the future of RFID innovation.
Chipless touting has been done for some years now. Chipless does represent a big threat somewhere in the future since the versatility of printing is ubiquitous, (if cheap enough and smart enough printers can be developed) just as bar-coding can be done at the customer’s site. So the initial chipless threat could be to barcoding. This was what the RFID market had talked about, but the cost is too high and the versatility limited (barcodes can even be printed on cans, paper goods, and virtually anything).
Studies and pilots have shown that this printed RFID can store data and perform. Though limited today, thin film transistor circuits current work continues to develop in order to make these practical and ‘reachable’ by the commercial market in the coming years. The key will be creating the equipment that can be deployed as widely as barcode printers. Though we are a long way off from that, many companies today use managed services to create their barcode or RFID labels. These end-user firms could actually turn to the converters they already work with to produce this next generation of products.
But the price a converter can afford to pay is limited — not millions per printer.
Most interesting is that players who are leading chipless are a completely different group of players, such as 3M, BASF, and others, who are in printing, papers, plastics, inks, and other materials rather than the semiconductor players.3 So innovation such as this could ‘up-end’ an industry. (Any major market here will be beyond the five-year forecast.)
Printed electronics hold the greatest promise for the future of RFID and other ID technologies. The market for printed electronics is growing as the processes and equipment to produce these on a mass scale is being optimized to lower the investment for producers to invest. Radiofrequency identification (RFID) tags, organic light emitting diodes (OLEDs), thin-film photovoltaic (PV), printed batteries, and sensors, all can be produced with printed electronics. Along with the printed ‘chip,’ technologies such as laser-structured antennas will create 3-dimensional antennas.4
“Inks and coatings are a key driver in printed electronics, with technologies ranging from metals such as silver and copper to carbon nanotubes. Because of the potential of the market, ink manufacturers large and small are developing products, from large multi-national companies such as Sun Chemical and DuPont to well-funded start-ups such as Plextronics, Kovio, and PolyIC.”5
Proliferation of Antennas
Let’s face it. RFID has challenges in being read — environments vary greatly. Applications vary greatly. And customers need readability assurance. As the RFID use cases and case studies grow, so does the demand to add new categories — categories with big potential. The solutions provider who can make the health and beauty market shine will reap big rewards, for example.
Diversity is a challenge, though. Just as in other hardware markets, computer-aided design has come to the RFID antenna market. NXP, for example, has introduced software product RFID – PCB Antenna Designer for UHF tags. Custom designers such as Kanemastu,6 Vizinex (RCD), as well as major tag producers, understand that versatility is important to penetrate other market segments.
Chip providers like Alien and Impinj have development platforms for their partners. And printer giants like Zebra publish standards and guidelines for antennas and inlay providers to design tags so that these products are compatible with theirs.
One challenge with antennas is quality. Just as in other ultra-thin electronic areas, manufacturing with extremely high quality takes a considerable investment in equipment and know-how. So, though the antenna is a critical component of the tag, there are actually only a few major producers in the world. And from a quality perspective, there is a difference in performance and reliability across the manufacturers.
Intelligent things and IoT applications often require the smarts to travel along with the asset. Firms like Tego are making big headway here with what they call smart assets. Surely this does increase the value of the asset. As supply chains, for example, crave more visibility, they need the smarts for high-risk/high-impact shipments. High-value assets as well as high-cost processes such as maintenance gain value from ongoing — off the grid — intelligence with high memory tags.
Already launched and gaining traction is thin film/read/write visual tags with electronic inks and/or paper already used by firms like Omni-ID.7 Supply Chain, Manufacturing process control, Scientific and lab, and many use cases abound where visual — graphics and instructions — need to accompany RFID. Omni-ID has significant traction in applications such as JIT/Kanban in mega manufacturing settings. Retail will be another market where dynamic pricing in stores is a challenge.8
Passive Plus Sensors
Here we are referring to passive (not battery assist) sensors combined with RFID. Firms like RFMicron are getting traction in the market with their product. Temperature, moisture, pressure vibration — all are things you want to know about — in thousands of use cases — not just assets or items but also the intelligent environments.9
Of course, the challenge — as always with RFID — is to focus on the high-value use cases with a clear customer/market buying into the use case. Sensors are old story. Our world abounds with them. But taking the next leap into the RFID + Sensor world has taken some time. But our forecast is showing significant growth in this area. Again IoT may be part of the catalyst, but day-to-day applications from construction, to perishables/cold chain (food and beverage, pharma, health and beauty), environmentally controlled processes, from industrial, to home applications can clearly benefit.
Battery Assisted Passive
Not actually ‘active,’ these UHF + battery or semi-active tags have a place in the ‘passive’ RFID
market. BAP (Battery Assisted Passive) tags differ from Active RFID in that they do not emit a beacon. Though they have a power source of their own, they wait, like passive to be interrogated. Why have BAP, then? BAP allows more other types of applications to be part of the RFID system.
The combination of UHF + power extends the read range of the UHF significantly, but allows it to be read by the same reader as other (non-battery) passive tags. This assists with multi-layer applications where cartons, for example, that may only need passive and within a container, that may require longer read range, be reusable, and need to store more data. These all can be part of one system vs. having multiple frequencies/protocols and the hardware that would need to accompany this.
This is and will remain a fairly small market due the smaller target market due to the cost/form factor of these tags. However, the effort to provide thinner batteries and tags, as well as reduce cost can assist this sector a great deal to achieve its potential growth.
Thinner and More Powerful
Thin is in! Thinness, compactness is a goal for RFID; in many of the designed applications there is a lot of research and efforts to achieve thin and more flexible tags.
One method that researchers from the University of North Dakota have developed is the Laser Enabled Advanced Packaging. Instead of using the pick-and-place robotic methods generally employed with today’s larger tags, a laser pulse is used to insert the RFID circuitry into a substrate: in this case, paper.10
Another is thin film11 — one method is creating circuits with low-temperature thin film technology.
Inlays future is also going to be thinner — and cheaper.
Nano technology is being applied both in the inks,14 as well as in tag and antenna materials.
In the future, a new generation of Nano-meta material — is being created. This allows for even smaller scale and ultimately cheaper technology. These are created with laser/optical lithography.
Meta materials according to research can be ‘tuned’ to different frequencies.15
For more …
Recent RFID Articles and Reports from ChainLink Research: http://www.chainlinkresearch.com/rfid/index.cfm
RFID Market – What Will It Take? (Discussion of what it will take to grow the RFID passive market)
Technology Adoption – Rethinking the Model – RFID Adoption Life Cycle
Continue receiving RFID updates by registering for the brief: http://www.chainlinkresearch.com/register/index.cfm
1 Please note, the author is not an engineer, so the inaccuracies that might be here I take full credit for! — Return to article text above
2 IDTechEX and Printed Electronics Now are two good sources. — Return to article text above
3 3M, BASF, Dai Nippon Printing, Inksure, Kovio, Phillips, PolyIC, Xerox, Toshiba — Return to article text above
4 LPFK http://www.lpkf.com/ has developed LDS technology to allow the printing of antennas. — Return to article text above
5 Source: Printed Electronics Now publication — Return to article text above
6 Contact: http://www.kanematsu.co.jp/tabid/119/Default.aspx?language=en-US — Return to article text above
7 Read The Value of Dynamic Visual Tagging — Return to article text above
8 Read The Price Is Right — <a href=”http://www.clresearch.com/research/detail.cfm?guid=B28189C8-3048-79ED-9940-3594856D6F93 — Return to article text above
9 Firms like RFMicron don’t just provide sensor-based RFID but also can create the sensor-based environment with special readers and software to collect and interpret the data — Return to article text above
10 http://www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?10472 — Return to article text above
11 https://projects.imec.be/oricla/sites/projects.imec.be.oricla/files/Imec%20%E2%80%93%20EU%20project%20reaches%20milestone%20for%20bi-directional%20thin-film%20RFID%20tags%20(Thin-Film%20RFID%20Tags)_07032012_ElectroPages.pdf — Return to article text above
12 http://spectrum.ieee.org/tech-talk/semiconductors/devices/smart-paper-makes-traceable-money-possible — Return to article text above
13 http://www.rfidjournal.com/articles/view?8287 — Return to article text above
14 Nano ink: http://www.nanowerk.com/news/newsid=15389.php — Return to article text above
( Other Nano articles: https://projects.imec.be/oricla/sites/projects.imec.be.oricla/files/European%20project%20reaches%20milestone%20bidirectional%20communication%20for%20thin-film%20RFIDs,%20enabling%20item-level%20RFID%20tags_23022012_Nanotechnology%20Now_0.pdf — Return to article text above )
15 http://www.shef.ac.uk/eee/research/cr/research/tuneable– Return to article text above
More on Meta Materials: http://spectrum.ieee.org/biomedical/imaging/metamaterials-breakthrough-brings-invisibility-closer
To view other articles from this issue of the brief, click here.